Hero-electric-05

Comparing costs: EV vs ICE

Total cost of ownership comparison

The cost gap between electric and internal combustion engine cars (ICE) is shrinking each year. However, their total costs are structured in slightly different ways, which is why we have put together a comprehensive comparison. When comparing costs it’s essential to look at the total cost of ownership. Some cost components are more expensive for EVs like tyres while others are much cheaper like energy. However, a lot of factors influence these savings. The total cost of ownership is made up of the following cost components.

What are the cost components?

  1. reportingDepreciation

    The depreciation of electric vehicles is higher than for internal combustion engine vehicles (ICE). The amount you pay for a leased electric vehicle is largely based on the expected depreciation. Electric vehicles will almost certainly be more advanced at the end of a two, three or four year lease. At the end of the contract, you will not have to worry about the residual value of the car.

  2. chargingEnergy & fuel costs

    Charging your car at home will also increase your electricity bill, but how much your bill increases depends on factors such as the charging time and where you live. Electricity costs can vary considerably from region to region. Remember that charging your car overnight can save you 30% on charging costs. Public charging stations are generally more expensive than home charging. The cost of charging an electric car at a public charging point depends on the network of charging points, the capacity of the charging points and the service provider. The price of public charging points also varies according to the power rating.

  3. maintenanceMaintenance

    Across all vehicle sizes, electric vehicles have lower maintenance costs than internal combustion engine vehicles relative to the price of the vehicle. Based on our TCO study, we can say that the cost is 11% lower. Electric vehicles have far fewer items requiring maintenance than ICE vehicles, which means that the maintenance costs of electric vehicles are much lower compared to ICE vehicles. Nevertheless, they still require regular maintenance, which is costly. Parts requiring maintenance include tyres, brakes, windscreens, wiper blades, washer fluid and battery. In addition, general wear and tear can incur costs.

  4. tyresTyres

    Drivers should bear in mind that because electric cars run on batteries, tyres must also be able to withstand the weight of the batteries. Electric car tyres need to have a stronger structure to withstand the weight of the battery and car components.

  5. body-repairDamage repair

    All vehicles, including ICE vehicles, are becoming increasingly complex in terms of high-tech features and new, more advanced electronics. Advanced electronics are also expensive to repair. Repairers need to invest in staff training and new equipment to work on electric vehicles. ICE vehicles also have more Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS). The advanced technological features that electric vehicles are packed with are expensive to replace. Batteries make electric vehicles heavier than similarly sized ICE vehicles. It also means electric cars use more expensive, lightweight, high-strength materials to try to balance the weight of the battery. These materials are also expensive to replace.

  6. insuranceInsurance 

    In general, electric vehicles cost more to insure than internal combustion vehicles. Because electric vehicles are more expensive to buy and repair, insurance companies charge more to insure an electric vehicle than an internal combustion engine car. Nevertheless, the savings you make on fuel and tax incentives can more than offset the extra costs.

  7. driving-costsTaxes

    Vehicle tax is payable annually on cars, vans and lorries registered in Finland and used in traffic. The vehicle tax consists of a basic tax and a circulation tax. The basic tax is usually based on the CO2 emission value of the vehicle, as reported by the manufacturer to Traficom. The vehicle excise duty is based on the total mass of the vehicle and its propulsion power. For petrol-driven cars, only the basic vehicle tax is charged. If the vehicle is powered or fuelled by another fuel, such as diesel or electricity, then the vehicle will also be subject to the basic tax and the vehicle tax.<for countries="" to="" add=""></for>

Are EVs cheaper to drive than ICE vehicles?

When it comes to EVs, fuel and vehicle maintenance costs are the primary factors in driving down the TCO. According to research by Ayvens, the total cost for electric vehicles - in most situations in Europe - are already cheaper than ICE vehicles, assuming costs are averaged over the first four years of ownership and an annual mileage of 30,000 km.

Read the whitepaper

ALD Automotive and ALD Carmarket are now Ayvens - your partner for sustainable mobility s…

 Ayvens was born from the acquisition of LeasePlan by ALD Automotive. In Finland, ALD Autototive wi…
28 August - 1 min to read

Interested in electrifying your fleet?

At Ayvens we have the experience to support your fleet transition